Best Comforters in 2019 – Buying Guide and Top Picks

Comforters have a significant impact on our sleep duration and quality. Our buying guide will give you a detailed insight into the best comforters in 2019, and provide you with the necessary information to make the right choice.

No matter the season, comforters have a significant impact on our sleep duration and quality. However, the perfect model is hard to find due to a wide variety of models on the market. Our guide will give you a detailed insight into the top 5 comforters in 2019 and provide you with all the necessary information on buying these products. Check out each product’s design and materials to help you choose your perfect fit.


The Best Comforters of 2019


Parachute Down Duvet Insert


  • Smooth cotton-sateen shell
  • Canadian goose down fill
  • Fitting for all seasons
  • Lightweight
  • 60-day trial

The Parachute Down Duvet Insert is the best down duvet insert comforter you can find on the market. This luxury option has Canadian goose down with a 750 fill power that will create a dense and lofty layer that can give excellent warmth in colder periods. The best thing is that it is available in two thicknesses options – a lightweight model and all-season model. Additionally, it has a Responsible Down certification for standard, meaning the production is sustainable and ethical. It also has a 60-day sleep trial.


Buffy Comforter


  • Cooling cover made from eucalyptus
  • Excellent warmth
  • Eco-friendly fill

The Buffy comforter is our editor’s pick for many reasons. It is an eco-friendly product that provides excellent temperature regulation during all seasons. The fill has a fluffy feel, but it is made from recycled plastic that gives excellent insulation and warmth. About fifty plastic bottles are cleared from the environment and used for the production of each comforter. The cover is made from eucalyptus, so it is very comfortable, breathable and it will stay cool even in hotter periods. It is an excellent choice for people who have sensitive skin. It is available in all sizes (Twin, Twin XL, Queen, King, Full and California King) with a free trial and shipped in a certified package, by the Forest Stewardship Council without any shipping or return fees.


Silk Camel Silk Comforter


  • Breathable
  • 100% silk fill
  • Provides excellent cooling

Our choice for the best lightweight comforter for hot sleepers is the Silk Camel Silk Comforter that is designed to give exceptional warmth and cooling while wicking away moisture. It is filled with mulberry silk – a natural material that is breathable and cool, encased in a cotton shell that is breathable and smooth. It is lightweight, with only four pounds, and available in King, Queen, Twin, and California King size. It also has corner and side clasps that will prevent it from slipping off you while you are sleeping.


Hanna Kay Down Alternative Quilted Comforter


  • Baffled construction
  • Warm fill
  • Machine-washable
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Very affordable

When searching for your perfect pick, the price is one of the most significant factors that can influence your buying decision. Some models even have prices within a three-figure range, but that does not mean good quality. This model is our pick for the best value. The filling of the Hanna Kay Down Alternative Quilted Comforter contains fluffy and hypoallergenic fibers, which will give you exceptional warmth and insulation from the cold. This model also has baffled stitching that will keep the fill evenly dispersed and prevent clumping. Unlike many expensive models, this one can be washed and dried in a machine, and it won’t lose its shape. The price of the product is low, less than $40.  


Tuft & Needle Down Alternative Duvet


  • Multiple weight options
  • Lofty fill
  • Cool cotton cover
  • Corner straps that will prevent any slippage
  • 100-day trial

The Tuft & Needle Down Alternative Duvet is the best down alternative duvet insert. It contains polyester microfibers – a popular material for comforters, which offers excellent softness and insulation similar to authentic down. Apart from that, down models are very inexpensive and hypoallergenic as well. The model is available in medium and light weights, and is perfect for different sleeping preferences. The lighter version is sewn through and it is thin, making it suitable for individuals who tend to sleep hot, and the medium option is Baffle-stitched, which helps to prevent the clumping of the material.  The smooth Cambric cotton encases the fill and ensures proper temperature regulation. Corner loops on the product prevent it from slipping off you while you are sleeping. Apart from that, the product has a 100-day sleep trial, free returns, and the warranty lasts for 3 years.


Sleep Restoration Down Alternative Comforter


  • Lofty
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Ten color options
  • Low-maintenance
  • 30-day sleep trial

Even though most of these products give an equal amount of warmth, some models are designed to offer a completely different sleep experience. For the best warm comforter, we recommend the Sleep Restoration Down Alternative Comforter. It is an oversized model padded with down alternative fibers in a dense cover that has baffled stitching for the additional shape retention. Unlike many other models, it is machine-washable and available in ten different colors. The price of this product is affordable, with less than $40, and a 30-day sleep trial. It is so popular with people that hotels often use them for their rooms.


Buying Guide

Comforters have many features and options that can make shopping difficult and to help you, we have gathered all the vital information you need to know when buying one. Take a look at our buying guide below!

Comforter vs. Duvet

A comforter is a thick, quilted, and fluffy blanket that is used to keep you warm or cool, depending on which you need. The fill usually contains synthetic fibers and is stitched or quilted to keep it secure and evenly distributed. Unlike a duvet, it only forms one piece of all of your bed linens. A duvet is sometimes referred to as a comforter; it is a soft and flat bag that is filled with feathers, down, wool, or some synthetic alternative to these. It has a removable cover that acts as a protective layer of the entire duvet and has a closure that you can remove and wash.

Types of Fabric Used

Finding the right material can make a difference in the comfort you have when you are sleeping or even just relaxing. However, it is not easy to choose the right one without trying it out, as the choice ultimately depends on personal preference.

There are many types of materials that are used for these products, but we are going to go over materials that are considered the most comfortable.


Cotton is a natural material that is very soft and comfortable. Comforters made from cotton offer exceptional breathability, temperature regulation, and comfort. Overall, they are an excellent choice if you sleep hot. Since it is a natural fiber, it is breathable and remains cool when in contact with your skin. It also has excellent moisture wicking abilities that help with temperature regulation of the bed.

You can find two types of cotton in these products – preshrunk sanforized cotton and mercerized cotton, which is made by putting cotton in a strong lye solution to be more absorbent, durable and colorfast. The best thing about cotton is that, as it ages, it gets better – it gets softer and even more comfortable. However, compared to other materials, it wrinkles often and can shrink if you don’t wash it properly.


Silk is made from the cocoon of the silkworm caterpillar, which is spun with a continuous silk strand. The natural and breathable material is as soft as down, but it stains easily and requires dry-cleaning. Comforters made from silk are typically available only in white or eggshell, with a duvet cover for protection. Unlike wool, but similar to cotton, silk is excellent for both winter and summer seasons – it can be cool or warm, depending on what you need. For allergy sufferers, silk is also an ideal choice of material. However, like wool, silk can be expensive.

Heavy silk models have around 400 grams per square meter (gsm) or more, while lightweight ones have around 200 gsm. Heavier products are best for getting more warmth in winter, while lighter ones are the best for the summer season. Silk models are also delicate and need gentle care, which means you can’t wash it in the washing machine. If you want to clean it, use a wet piece of cloth to wipe it.


Bamboo comforters are starting to be popular thanks to their amazing properties. They are very luxurious without costing a fortune. Based on the manufacturing process, there are a few variations of bamboo models. Some of them resemble silk have the same benefits of silk for a cheaper price, while others are more like cashmere. They have excellent breathability and softness, but they do retain some warmth.


Because of the naturally hypoallergenic properties of wool, these products are an excellent choice for individuals that have sensitive skin. Wool is a natural fiber that can provide softness and warmth, wick away moisture, moderate body temperature, and resist smells and bacteria. During the winter, it will keep you warm, but even though you can use wool in the summer, people usually avoid it. It is also very soft, lightweight, and flame retardant. However, it is also expensive, because wool fibers are spun from the fleece of different animal hair breeds such as cashmere goats, angora rabbits, alpacas, and so on. Comforters that have wool in their construction are comfortable and soft, but not always machine-washable. Instead, you should dry clean them or use warm water and mild detergent for removing small stains. After that, you can rinse the washed area with cold water, but avoid using chemicals and bleach because they will destroy the fabric.


Polyester is a synthetic filling material that can be found in more-affordable options. It’s often the ideal material for allergies because the fibers are non-allergenic. Although it is not as breathable as natural-fiber fills, it offer durability and affordability. You can wash it in the washer/dryer, and it dries quickly. However, since traps moisture and heat, this type of material may be uncomfortable during warmer seasons.


Comforters made from down are lightweight and offer high levels of comfort and warmth. The air trapped between small pieces of down will give the right amount of heat and breathability. The most expensive ones are with the pure white goose down, while those that use a mixture of feathers are less-expensive. However, most down models are not machine-washable.

Fill Power

Fill power is the main attribute of down and down alternative comforters. It is the volume or the number of ounces of down in a product. The fill weight is also the primary driver of warmth – the higher the fill power, the higher the volume and warmth. The power can vary depending on different factors, such as whether the fill is from goose or duck and if it is a feather or cluster. At 400 or less fill power, there is less loft, and you can get limited warmth. From 400 to 599, the product will have better heat retention and give you more warmth. However, the loft is still limited, so it might not give you enough warmth for colder periods. Between 600 and 799 is the most suitable for all-season models and even higher-end winter models. The amount of loft in this range of fill power will trap heat and provide you with a cozy sleep environment. A down comforter with more than 800 fill power will have denser feathers and clusters that will offer exceptional levels of durability, softness, and warmth.


The construction refers to the extra stitching on the interior that prevents the fill material from shifting and creating dead spaces and lumps. Most fill materials tend to have these issues, so it is essential to find the one that will fit your preferences.

Thread Count

Thread count is the density of the fabric used per square inch. If the thread count is higher, the product will be more durable, but also softer. If the weave is denser, it will stop the fill from pouring out of the comforter. The thread count usually ranges from 300 to more than 800. For most shells, TC is between 300 and 400 – it can retain the fill and be smooth. A slightly tighter weave, from 400 to 500, will add extra durability. Having a thread count between 500 and 800 is not much different compared to lower TC, but sometimes, the models with a higher number will have two-ply yarns in the weaving instead of more threads. The same goes for the ones with more than 800.


Comforters should cover the entire bed, so it is vital to match the size. They are available in many sizes, including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Full/Queen, Queen (including Oversized), King, California King (including Oversized King). However, some variations are possible with the dimensions, so you should always check the exact measurements, and they can somewhat differ from mattress sizes.

Sleep Related

Was this post helpful?

Leave a Comment